| Year | Winners | State | Program | College |
| 2004 | Danielle Marie Murphy | Colorado | Fast Pitch | Univ. of Evansville |
| 2005 | Kristin Marie Krueger | Colorado | Fast Pitch | Otero Jr. College |
| 2006 | Maureen McDaniel | Colorado | Fast Pitch | Regis Univ. |
| 2006 | Cassandra Caley | Colorado | Fast Pitch | U. of Colorado |
| 2008 | Kaitlyn Shelby Lanteri | Colorado | Fast Pitch | Chadron State College |
| 2008 | Morgan Leigh Lanteri | Colorado | Fast Pitch | Chadron State College |